The full page ad in last Saturday's Honolulu Advertiser had the compelling headline:
"We've got a hard choice: Roll over/Get Tough."
The ad, which was placed by Oceanic Cable's parent company Time Warner Cable, bemoaned the soaring costs of television programming, which have been as high as 300 percent. (See:)
"Sometimes a network will threaten to take your shows away if we don't roll over," the ad said. "The networks shouldn't be in the driver's seat on what you watch and how much you pay."
The ad asks consumers to choose between rolling over or getting tough with the networks.
The Time Warner ad campaign is part of a nationwide battle between large cable operators and the networks.
Under the Federal Communications Commission's so-called "must carry" rule, cable companies are required to carry local channels. The rates to run the programming, also known as retransmission fees, are not set by the FCC but are negotiated by the cable operators and the networks and broadcasters.
Those rates have soared in recent years due to consolidation in the broadcast industry and as costs for broadcasters have risen.
In Cedar Rapids, Iowa, consumers face the prospect of losing access to their local CBS and Fox affiliates due to a dispute over retransmission fees.
Cable operator Mediacom has asked the Federal Communications Commission to bar Sinclair Broadcast Group of Baltimore from blocking its CBS and Fox channels while they continue talks over the fees.
Several years ago, Mediacom lost the feed for the CBS station in Iowa for four weeks due to a similar dispute over retransmission fees.
In Hawaii, the recent shared services agreement between KHNL, K5 and KGMB9 raises some concern about increased transmission fees.
While we're not likely to see replay of the Iowa situation, local consumers could see higher rates as a result of the recent shared services agreement between KHNL, K5 and KGMB9.
Gerald Kato, board member of Media Council Hawaii which is opposing the KHNL-KGMB pact, said controlling three stations gives Alabama-based Raycom considerable leverage on Oceanic when it comes to setting its retransmission fees.
Raycom and Time Warner officials had no immediate comment when asked about retransmission fees.
"This is one of the concerns of consolidation," said Kato, a University of Hawaii-Manoa journalism professor.